Stats:
- Route: Standard Routes from South Colony Lake
- Distance:
- Approach (South Colony), 8 miles round trip
- Climb, 6.5 miles round trip
- Elevation Gain:
- Approach, ~1,700
- Climb, ~5,500 feet
- Start time: 7:00 AM
- Time:11 hours
- Climbers: Alan, David, Seth, Angela, Sandy
I reminded myself that loosely made plans are always fun. With that Alan and I left the trailhead at 7 PM, knowing that the Texans would be hiking up in the dark that night, finding our site, making camp and then be ready for the Crestones the following morning.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/92023/92023776e9e8dcaeccf82e560d46ade84d4e4375" alt="IMG_6109 IMG_6109"
Lets go for hike! Alright, but only if we can dress the same!
We were 5 minutes down the trail when I looked left and noticed a bear. As trained we immediately raised our packs above our heads, made noise and stood close together to appear larger…that is a complete lie. In true tourist fashion we immediately reached for cameras. We were fast, the bear faster. All we got was one blurry image, which could actually be a yeti.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c01ce/c01ce8c409593228467562a798655ae7b3cfc928" alt="IMG_6112 IMG_6112"
That black blurry thing in the middle? Bear, thankfully running away.
We found a great campsite. The Texans found us. Morning arrived. We hiked.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e5314/e531463fac63b2f2e4ca99376ac71f2845003a4d" alt="IMG_6116 IMG_6116"
Left to right: David, Seth, Angela, Sandy, Alan, Crestone Needle
The climb up to Broken Hand Pass was dry at the base but snowchoked as it neared the top. Crampons were unnecessary, but an ice axe needed. As an admitted gearhead, standing in such a beautiful basin, necessary equipment and knowhow at hand and watching friends move across the snow as the morning sun gathers strength, it is impossible to not smile.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c6194/c6194a341fa902f43fb7b5ea18a9be71bd184347" alt="IMG_6123 IMG_6123"
David and Angela on the first snowfield of the day
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2f120/2f1200930a4ba1e914a886854d00360e4fa965f4" alt="IMG_6124 IMG_6124"
Sandy crossing snow
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ce031/ce03116a1d4b23b5491f22fd937b557ad43284fe" alt="IMG_6125 IMG_6125"
Alan as the climbing steepens
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d36c7/d36c7f30146ddf32217c375f90d5422beb3a482e" alt="IMG_6135 IMG_6135"
The team atop Broken Hand Pass
From Broken Hand Pass we followed the obvious trail and were quickly in the East Gully. The crossover to the West Gully is easy to find, especially with the photo from the 14ers.com route description. The gullies both had a thread of snow, which could be avoided and/or were located in areas where they were of little consequence.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/43657/43657e37e397fcca25006308f65589d5a314c8b3" alt="IMG_6142 IMG_6142"
Alan skylines himself while route finding
As someone who is comfortable with exposure, I found the climbing fun. This peak was a little intimidating as the last time I was in the area there was a fatality on the Needle. This was always in the back of mind, but also served to sharpen focus, but anxiety turned to joy with each upward step.
We spent 30 sun soaked minutes on the summit. We had seen one climber descending and otherwise had the Needle to ourselves. As the trailhead lot was full it begged the question: Where was everybody?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/60f78/60f7812b288bf9d5b1d1841774ab7bfa39af0b5c" alt="IMG_6150 IMG_6150"
Alan on the summit, with the next objective, Crestone Peak in the background.
The original plan was to do the traverse from Needle to Peak, but we did not have 100% buy-in from the group, and frankly I did not want to carry a rope, so I used this an excuse to call it off. Instead, Seth, Alan and I decided we would leave from Broken Hand Pass and climb Crestone Peak via the standard route.
The descent back to Broken Hand Pass was uneventful, but an exercise in methodical downclimbing.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c6d31/c6d3132dea34ffcc7bdcadb0846bc9029fae6f6f" alt="IMG_6159 IMG_6159"
Sandy and David on the descent
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/676d4/676d4343d8d341e9dd278ca0b29c437c9df21132" alt="IMG_6163 IMG_6163"
David, Angela and Seth crossing over a rib
Alan and I have gotten a lot of hiking in this year and Seth is the type of guy who runs ultra-marathons and occasionally wins them. We meshed perfectly as we dropped off the pass, quietly consuming distance, cruised by Cottonwood Lake and made the hard right towards the Red Gully. Snow streaked, flowing with water and the snow softening in the sun, we quickly discussed the route and then ascended without pause.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ac62d/ac62d5f1be31115154aeb4e4a8f931d4717af15c" alt="IMG_6165 IMG_6165"
We stayed in the rocks to the left side in the lowest snow field, switched to right midway, crossed an unavoidable snowfield and then cut back left, ultimately reaching the summit left of the upper snowfield. This kept us out of soft snow, but put us on steep terrain.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/194be/194befaf7e9a2849033351a07d89ca56ac7aafa1" alt="IMG_6166 IMG_6166"
Approaching the base of the Red Gully, note the running water
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d83ce/d83ce0bf834723909368f7c4eeffeaf511dc7053" alt="IMG_6168 IMG_6168"
Hugging the left side of the lower snowfield
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fa815/fa8159b34b49d8af73230291ce0857bffac3b4a5" alt="IMG_6170 IMG_6170"
Alan and Seth high above the basin floor
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0a50e/0a50e554f5c433ed292710d7d52631d0b903a1c3" alt="IMG_6171 IMG_6171"
Seth and Alan crossing a small but steep snowfield, en route to dry rock
Two hours after departing Broken Hand Pass we reached the summit. We laid into our food supply, finished our water (damn it!) and drank in views of neighboring peaks, the Sand Dunes and the expanse of the San Luis Valley. Then summit goofiness began.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b13e/0b13ee8f7a33e008beef01e8f57f52977a550680" alt="IMG_6181 IMG_6181"
Alan throwing down the “farmer flex shot” with a hat he found at 14,000 feet.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/91d86/91d86e95b0a44067158431508191b89de766bf92" alt="IMG_6174 IMG_6174"
The classis pose, note the socks, so much for “waterproof’ boots. The Full Monty showed up too but is not safe for viewing as it requires immediate administration of eye bleach.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ece1e/ece1e71ce38d9c10132dfa073dc2a60fbf4d998c" alt="IMG_6184 IMG_6184"
Seth and Alan
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/69460/6946021c04b72c9e795a91c4cf1af5b3e7358e5b" alt="IMG_6183 IMG_6183"
Kit Carson and Challenger
The descent was a thirsty affair, luckily the exposure was such that one did not notice the dry and scratchy throat. After the initial scramble we were able to transition to snow and plunge step.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a7718/a7718133a7882cf470e13e37005c002cfc1e02f8" alt="IMG_6189 IMG_6189"
Alan downclimbing
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d97c0/d97c0692ec80eaf69ebde900e4c477fd2644764f" alt="IMG_6191 IMG_6191"
Seth and Sandy plunge stepping
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e869d/e869d7c28c3f29607f0f98c6e752388ced5118af" alt="IMG_6193 IMG_6193"
Water water everywhere
We filtered water at Cottonwood Lake, climbed back over Broken Hand Pass and hit camp for ramen and rest. Tempted by the lure of sleeping in our own beds, Alan and I packed and drove back to Denver.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c8832/c88324b440ab963e38309052aaf7908bcb4a6944" alt="IMG_6194 IMG_6194"
Climb complete
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/95689/956893e966055330ddacfaf95effa7ca559f8058" alt="IMG_6195 IMG_6195"
Cottonwood Lake
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/507de/507deed182935c42375c7dab6cecaf5234d174d4" alt="IMG_6197 IMG_6197"
The sun slips behind the Crestones
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0576b/0576b67f5da3b79938a360337d3a8bf4c31dd797" alt="photo1 photo1"
The road home
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/201a9/201a9bc419a77e1808fa054b2786d87812433fc5" alt="photo photo"
Second dinner!